Beware of rushing to judgement before terminating employment.

A Tribunal has ruled that a deputy security manager was unfairly dismissed, despite performing “no prescribed tasks” while ‘working from home’, many hundreds of miles from his place of work. Mr. Kitaruth travelled from London to Cornwall to visit with his parents for four days, during which the hearing found no evidence that he did any work.

When his line manager, Mr. Stride of OCS Security Ltd., summoned him to a mid-week meeting in the office he learned of Mr. Kitaruth's location leading to his subsequent dismissal for "gross misconduct". However, Mr. Kitaruth won his case for unfair dismissal after the Tribunal found that the company had failed to interview the line manager during their investigation.

Mr. Kitaruth told the Tribunal that he had an informal arrangement in which he verbally agreed with Mr. Stride on the dates that he would ‘work from home’, as August was a quiet month at the conference centre. The Tribunal found that Mr. Kitaruth “genuinely believed he had been given permission” although there was possibly of a misunderstanding arising between himself and his line manager, as evidenced by the message train on WhatsApp. Despite the pretext of 'working from home' there was no evidence that he had performed any tasks and, although he responded to "calendar invites, phone calls, liaising with the officers and emails,” he did not do so in a timely manner.

Judge Tamara Lewis noted that it was “extremely poor practice” for the company to take just six weeks to investigate and dismiss Mr. Kitaruth, and then to take a further seven and a half months to hear and reject his appeal. Moreover, the Judge found that "no reasonable employer would have failed to interview Mr. Stride formally before reaching a decision to dismiss the claimant," and hence, "For this reason, the dismissal was unfair.”

Employers should always publish, adopt, and follow to the letter any formal disciplinary procedures before terminating the employment of any contracted employee.